Provincial investigation into Edmonton Police Commission provokes questions on podcast
The provincial investigation of two of city council's appointments to the Edmonton Police Commission has raised concerns about accountability, the co-hosts of Episode 292 of Speaking Municipally said.
On Jan. 15, The Edmonton Police Service asked Mike Ellis, the minister of public safety and emergency services, to investigate the appointment of former police officer and criminologist Dan Jones and Renée Vaugeois, the executive director of the John Humphrey Centre for Peace and Human Rights to the commission.
"Why in the world would the (police) service have a say on who is holding them accountable and governing them?" co-host Troy Pavlek said. "How could that ever make sense?"
In a news release, EPS said it could not disclose its specific concerns, and only said they relate to "public-facing activities undertaken by the two appointees in either private or professional capacities." Postmedia obtained documents that suggest Edmonton Police Service leadership opposes the two people council appointed because of their comments about police matters, which include open police use-of-force investigations. The documents suggest EPS leadership has a problem with Jones and Vaugeois's respective participation in Safer For All, a documentary about police violence and accountability released last year. Jones has since resigned from the commission.
The commission will soon be tasked with recruiting a new chief of Edmonton's police service, as Chief Dale McFee is set to retire in February. "The makeup of the commission is critically important right now because the commission will be deciding who will be the chief of police in Edmonton for the next few years," Pavlek said.
Meanwhile, the province chose to reappoint Anne-Marie Lambert to the commission despite city council choosing not to renew her term in December. The commission itself elected former city councillor Ben Henderson as its chair in December, taking over for John McDougall, who resigned following backlash over his decision to be a member of the commission remotely from Portugal until 2026. Henderson said one of the reasons he decided to step into the chair position was to rebuild relationships between the commission, the police service, and council.
Co-host Mack Male said Henderson will have his work cut out for him. "Given the recent changes here — the request for an investigation, and the appointment, non-appointment of Lambert — it's a tough road ahead to try to rebuild those relationships, and a lot of it will centre around the new police chief," Male said.
The Jan. 24 episode of Taproot's civic affairs podcast includes a dissection of Paths for People's "bold" vision for 76 Avenue and the Edmonton Metropolitan Region Board's decision to wrap operations. Plus, Taproot's managing editor, Tim Querengesser, provides an update from the Taproot newsroom. Speaking Municipally comes out on Fridays. Listening and subscription options are all right here.