Housing advocates on both sides unhappy with proposed infill changes
As Edmonton city council prepares to decide what to do with some proposed changes to bylaws governing infill, neither opponents nor supporters of infill development are likely to be satisfied with the outcome.
Council's urban planning committee decided not to make a recommendation to council on two infill-related matters after hearing from dozens of residents on Feb. 9 and 10. Administration had recommended lowering the maximum number of units that can be built mid-block from eight to six in the RS zone, which applies to most mature neighbourhoods, as well as increasing the minimum lot size for each unit. Administration had recommended against making amendments to lower the maximum height allowance and to protect trees on private property.
All of this is now on city council's agenda for Feb. 17, with continuation scheduled for Feb. 18. If council supports making changes, administration will draft amendments to be debated at a public hearing, probably on April 7.
Before urban planning committee met on the matter, Taproot spoke to two advocates on either side of the infill debate: Dallas Moravec of Edmonton Neighbourhoods United and Jacob Dawang of Grow Together Edmonton. For Moravec, the proposed changes did not go far enough.
"It's the massing and the volume of the buildings that's actually creating the problem," said Moravec, a real estate agent whose group seeks to amplify the voices of residents who oppose multi-unit infills in mature neighbourhoods. "If we don't actually limit the length, the height, the width of the buildings … we don't feel like it's actually going to solve the problem."
On the other hand, Dawang worried that any further restrictions on infill could turn back important progress in Edmonton. His group sees infill as integral to housing sustainability and affordability.
Zoning that restricted development in mature neighbourhoods before "created a city where the only choice that many people had, if you could not afford a single-family home, was either to go out into the suburbs or maybe hope one day that you could afford a single-family home," Dawang said, adding that restricting infill "will give us less homes, it'll be pushing people out towards the suburbs once again, it'll be excluding people from neighbourhoods."